FHA is Changing Their Mortgage Insurance in October – How will this Change Your Borrowing Power?
15th September 2010
FHA is now the big dog in the mortgage market. FHA allows a low 3.5% down payment, and with conventional
guidelines ratcheting consistently tighter, more and more home buyers are choosing FHA as the way to buy. But over the last few years, as FHA has increased their market share, a chorus of doubters have been crying about how FHA is the next subprime, and with the low down payment the program is a ticking time bomb waiting to explode. I’ve pointed out before that though it is a government program, FHA has been self supportive since it started way back in the 1930s. While Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and all the big banks have required bailouts to stay in business, FHA has kept on chugging along. FHA doesn’t make loans directly. It acts more like a mortgage insurance company guaranteeing loans made to their guidelines and covering losses with the mortgage insurance premiums it collects. Up until now the insurance has been enough to cover all losses and so far they still have about two billion dollars in a reserve fund. But because FHA has increased its market share so much and the housing market and economy are still so stressed, FHA is now making changes to make sure the program stays financially sound. Over the last year FHA has tinkered around with their structure and come up with a variety of plans to shore up the reserve fund. Starting on October 4th, FHA will be changing the way they charge the insurance, and this will mean some home buyers will have a harder time qualifying, but it may work out better for others.
FHA breaks their mortgage insurance into two parts. One is an up-front mortgage insurance that is a percentage of the mortgage amount and added back into and financed over the life of the loan. The other part is an annual insurance paid each month (like private mortgage insurance). Currently, this breaks down to an up-front payment of 2.25% of the mortgage financed into the loan, and an annual payment of .55% per year, divided by 12 and paid monthly. The new changes will give with one hand, while taking away with the other. The good news is that the up-front increase will drop in a big way, down to 1% of the loan amount. The bad news is that the annual factor increases up to .90% (again, divided by 12) for those making the minimum down payment.
To see how this will affect new buyers, let’s compare the new version with the old (we won’t count taxes or insurance to keep this simple).
To compare, we will base this on -
- Purchase price $200,000
- 30 year fixed rate at 4.5%
- 3.5% minimum down payment of $7,000
- Base mortgage amount of $193,000
Under the current program it will look like this:
Up-Front mortgage insurance – $4,342 – Total mortgage amount of $197,342 – This gives a payment of just under $1,000. The monthly mortgage insurance premium (.55% divided by 12) adds $90 per month for a total payment of $1,090.
This is how it will work with the new plan:
Up-Front mortgage insurance – $1,930 – Total mortgage amount of $194,930 – This gives a payment of $988. The monthly mortgage insurance premium (.90% divided by 12) will add $146 per month for a total payment of $1,134.
With the new plan you will save $2,412 in the up-front charges, which mean more initial equity since this won’t be added on to your mortgage. But the flip side is that your monthly payment increases by $44 per month. For most home buyers $44 isn’t going to make or break a deal, though it will tip the scales for some. This is still the most affordable loan available. One thing to keep in mind is that the mortgage insurance decreases slightly every month because it is based on the current balance of the loan. So as you pay down the loan balance the monthly insurance will decrease. Another thing to keep in mind is that FHA mortgage insurance is tax deductable (as is conventional mortgage insurance, at least through the end of 2010). If you are in the 30% tax bracket, this means an additional $15 per month after tax savings with the above examples (the current break down spreads the benefit over a much longer time).
For many, even though the monthly payment will increase, this will turn out to be a better structure in the long run:
- For those who don’t plan on being in the home long term, the lower up-front MIP is more important than a slightly higher monthly payment. Most home buyers won’t stay in their home for ever, 7 years is the average.
- If you are buying a home that is undervalued (maybe a foreclosure that needs work and you are doing it with an FHA 203k rehab loan) you may be able to refinance it later and get rid of the mortgage insurance entirely.
- I am also advising buyers I work with to ask the seller to pay the 1% Up-Front MIP. Seller concessions are common now, and this will cut the payment down a little further.
- This will also work out better for many home buyers who could qualify for a conventional mortgage, but would be subject to Loan Level price Adjustments (price hits, for everything from credit scores to property type).
The bottom line is that this will hurt some borrowers and those will be the ones who are already stretching to get into a home. But by lowering the cost of getting into an FHA mortgage, the unintended consequence may be that it pulls in more borrowers who could go conventional if they wanted to. This may not be the result they were looking for, but my guess is that this change will bring in new buyers to FHA will add to the market share. If this change makes the program more stable, it will be worth it.
Peter Thompson 630-479-6424
Illinois Mortgage Rates First time home buyer loans
Chicago Mortgage Company Chicago FHA mortgages
Posted in FHA, First Time Home Buyers, Mortgage Programs | Comments Off



or take out home equity for other purposes. Being able to take equity out of your home has always been a big benefit of owning real estate, though it grew to an absurd degree during the bubble years. It’s not so easy to take cash out now. For one thing the standards have been raised and lenders now require more equity retained in the home. But the bigger issue is that with home values down, many home owners have lost equity, and many are upside down owing, more on their mortgages than their home is worth. This has led to the newest major trend in lending, the Cash/In
be the lowest real rates ever. Getting a fixed rate mortgage makes a whole lot of sense for any one who is pretty sure that they will be in their home for a long time. But even now, even with fixed rates as low as they are, fixed rate mortgages aren’t the right choice for everyone. Adjustable Rate Mortgages (ARMs) are priced even lower, and though you are taking on some extra risk, they are the best choice for many. The question is, when does it make sense to go with an adjustable rate mortgage. ARMs are structured in different ways, but the most popular, and safest ARMs are the longer term adjustables which are fixed for a period of time before adjusting. Most ARMs amortize, or pay down, over 30 years, just like the most popular fixed rates. The difference is that the rate is only fixed in for a specific period of time, and then it floats, up or down based on what is happening in the market. The time that the rate is fixed in can be as short as one year, or as long as 10 years. The rates are usually lowest for the shortest periods because you are taking on more risk that the loan will be higher if
the mid or even low 5s), are now considered high. You may be able to lower your payment by a lot, often with no closing costs. For homeowners that are able to take advantage of the lower rates, this can mean big savings over time. With home prices lower and tougher qualifying requirements, refinancing is tougher than it used to be. But there are still a number of mortgage programs which make it easier to
Good news for many short sale and foreclosure buyers, Congress passed and President Obama has now signed a bill to give homebuyers another three months to close on their home loans and receive tax credits up to $8,000 ($6,500 for move up buyers). The bill applies ONLY to homebuyers who had a signed contract to purchase a home by the April 30, 2010 deadline. The bill extends the deadline to September 30, 2010, for homebuyers to close on their real estate transaction.
passed by the Senate, will increase the monthly mortgage insurance for
and these changes mean it will be more expensive for
is that a record number of homeowners are in default and can’t pay their mortgages. A home foreclosure is a tragedy for the home owner and a problem for the community. The wave of foreclosures has also wreaked havoc in the mortgage industry. I don’t have much sympathy for the banks that made the loans because they knew what they were doing, or should have, and they made too many risky loans when the housing market was riding high. But the foreclosure wave has also had a big impact on the buyers who want to buy a home now, and it is effecting what they can afford and how they can qualify.
